
Citation: | Fanhui Bu, Lianyong Xu, Hongyang Jing, Hongning Pang, Yongdian Han, Lei Zhao. Influence of the repair length on the residual stress in P92 steel repair welds[J]. CHINA WELDING, 2020, 29(2): 17-22. DOI: 10.12073/j.cw.20200215002 |
P92 steel is widely used in supercritical steam pipes to reduce the weight of the pipes and boiler and improve the pipe system’s flexibility to achieve excellent creep performance and high temperature strength[1-2]. However, some defects may be exposed due to improper welding processes or damage incurred during the installation of P92 steel, which pose a significant threat to the safe operation of the equipment. After the occurrence of relevant defects, it is usually necessary to repair them by repair welding, which is economical and helps to maintain the structural integrity of the system. As a ferritic heat-resistant steel, the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of P92 steel can contain type-Ⅳ cracks, which may eventually cause structural failure. Some research has shown that residual stress has an important influence on type-Ⅳ cracks[3]. Therefore, it is of great theoretical significance and engineering application value to research the distribution of residual stress arising in P92 steel during the repair-welding process.
With the booming development of computer technology, the finite element method (FEM) is widely used for the prediction of residual stress. Based on plates of different shapes, Qiao
Based on the finite element simulation software SYSWELD, as well as existing models and experimental data presented in the literature, this paper verifies the feasibility of SYSWELD in simulating the residual stress distribution of P92 steel welding, simulating the repair welding process of P92 steel plates, and analyzing the residual stress field obtained by different repair welding lengths, to determine the influence of the weld length on the residual stress generated during repair welding.
The length, width and height of the welded sheet are 200 mm, 200 mm and 10 mm, respectively, as shown in Fig 1. As shown in Fig 2, when constructing 3D mesh, to improve the calculation efficiency and obtain an accurate solution, the mesh in the weld area and HAZ was more densely distributed, while the mesh was distributed more sparsely in positions far from the weld.
The simulation process was divided into butt welding, repair welding and heat treatment. The simulated butt welding consisted of multi-layer and multi-pass welding, while the repair welding was conducted during a single pass. The welding method consisted of argon tungsten arc welding, where the welding parameters are shown in Table 1. Post weld heat treatment, the parameters of which are shown in Fig 3, was conducted after the butt-welding and repair-welding steps. Under the assumption that the welding material and the base material have the same material properties, the specific material performance parameters are shown in Fig 4.
Layer | Welding current I /A | Arc voltage U/V | Welding speed v /(mm.s−1) |
1 | 100 | 10 | 1 |
2–3 | 125 | 12 | 1 |
4 | 125 | 15 | 1 |
repair weld | 130 | 20 | 1 |
In the simulations, the initial temperature and room temperature were both set to 20 ℃. As shown in Fig 2, to prevent the rigid displacement of the specimen during the welding process, the grid model had rigid constraints along the x and y directions. The 3D, x, y and z directions were respectively set at the three endpoints of the specimen.
To ensure the reliability of the material parameters and simulated results, the test data and model, which are shown in Fig 5, consisted of a length of 200 mm, a width of 200 mm, a height of 6 mm, a weld width of 10 mm and a penetration depth of 2 mm; these parameters were chosen to coincide with those used in Deng’s study[10], and which were used to verify the P92 simulated processes considered in this paper. Fig. 6 shows the comparison between the simulation results of residual stress in this study and the simulation results in Deng’s study and the measured residual stress values using the blind hole method. It can be seen from the figure that the distribution of the residual stress calculated by the P92 model established in this study is basically consistent with the simulated distribution seen in the literature study, and the measured distribution in the blind hole method(BHD). These results indicate that the material parameters and simulation results adopted here can be used to successfully simulate P92 welding and its repair welding process.
In the temperature distribution field of the welded section shown in Fig 7, it can be seen that the gray area, in which the temperature is higher than the melting point of P92 steel (1350 ℃), is larger than the area of the cut groove. Therefore, it is considered that the weld had reached the melting state during the repair-welding process.
Fig. 8 shows a distribution diagram of transverse and longitudinal residual stresses after repair welding, and it can be seen that tensile stress appears in the weld and in the vicinity of the HAZ. The transverse and longitudinal residual stresses are below 330 MPa and 480 MPa, respectively, while the maximum residual stresses occur in the HAZ.
The residual stresses of 60 mm, 100 mm, and 140 mm long repair welds were simulated using the welding parameters of a 100 mm long repair weld. To analyze the residual stress distribution in more detail, three important paths (Fig. 9) were selected in this paper, among which P1 occurs along the symmetry axis of the structure, P2 is located in the HAZ, and P3 is located in the center of the repair weld. According to the related literature research[11], type-Ⅳ cracks generally appear in a fine-grained HAZ in which the temperature is higher than Ac3 (900–920 ℃), and the critical HAZ has a temperature range between Ac1 (800–835 ℃) and Ac3. Therefore, it is very important to choose the appropriate path (P2) in the HAZ. As shown in Fig. 10, this paper extracted thermal cycle curves at three points (a, b, and c), which are marked in Fig. 7b. During the repair welding, it can be seen that the highest temperatures of points a, b, and c are 958 ℃, 910 ℃, and 863 ℃, respectively. Point b shows the presence of type-Ⅳ cracks, hence, path P2 choose the line where point b is.
Fig. 11 shows the influence of the repair welding length on the surface residual stress (P1). The transverse residual stress augments gradually from the center of the weld to the edge of the weld, decreases dramatically in the HAZ, increases gradually after passing through the HAZ, and then decreases gradually after reaching the peak. The longitudinal residual stress gradually increases from the center to the edge of the weld, and then gradually declines. By comparing the influence of different repair welding lengths on the residual stress along the P1 path, it is found that with an increase of the repair welding length, the horizontal stress level shows a gradually declining trend, while changes in the longitudinal stress are not obvious.
In our study of repair welds of different lengths, the normalized distance and the ratio of the starting point length of repair welding to the respective repair welding length were considered. Fig. 12 shows the influence of the repair welding length on the residual stress in the HAZ. For repair welds of different lengths, as the repair welding length increases, the transverse residual stress in the HAZ decreases gradually, while the effect on the longitudinal residual stress is less.
Fig. 13 shows the influence of the repair welding length on the weld’s residual stress. With an increase of repair welding length, both the transverse residual stress and the longitudinal residual stress show a decreasing trend.
(1) After the repair welding process, the tensile stresses of the repair welding seam and in the nearby HAZ were relatively large, while the stress of the base material was relatively small.
(2) In terms of transverse residual stress, as the repair welding length increased, the stress at the center of the structure surface, the stress in the HAZ and the stress at the weld line, all tended to decrease.
(3) In terms of longitudinal residual stress, the stress in the weld center tended to decrease with an increase of the weld length, but the length had no effect on the structure’s center and the HAZ.
[1] |
Zhao Y T. Microstructure and property and application of P92 steel used to ultra supercritical boiler. BeiJing: Metallurgical Industry Press, 2015.
|
[2] |
Jing H Y, Li S B, Xu L Y. Test of high temperature fracture toughness of P92 steel. Transactions of the China welding Institution, 2019, 40(2):8 − 12, 72.
|
[3] |
Allen D J, Harvey B and Brett S J. "FOURCRACK" - An investigation of the creep performance of advanced high alloy steel welds. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 2007, 84(1 − 2):104 − 113. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpvp.2006.09.010
|
[4] |
Qiao L, Han T. Effect of geometric shape of plate on residual stress and deformation distribution for butt - weld joint. China Welding, 2018, 27(3):20 − 26.
|
[5] |
Ni Y Z, Xu H, Chang Y, et al. Research on elastic-plastic creep damage of notched P92 steel specimens. Materials at High Temperatures, 2018, 35(4):335 − 342. doi: 10.1080/09603409.2017.1335961
|
[6] |
Zhang J Q, Zhang G D, Guo J L. Finite element simulation of interfacial creep failure of welded joints of HR3C/T91 heat resistant steel. Transactions of the China welding Institution, 2017, 38(10):11 − 15. (in Chinese)
|
[7] |
Liu X Z. Investigation of the influence of solid-state phase transformation on welding residual stress in muti-pass P92 steel joint. Chongqing: Chongqing University, 2015.
|
[8] |
Jiang Wenchun, Xu X P, Gong J M, et al. Influence of repair length on residual stress in the repair weld of a clad plate. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2012, 246:211 − 219. doi: 10.1016/j.nucengdes.2012.01.021
|
[9] |
Jiang W C, Liu Z B, Gong J M, et al. Numerical simulation to study the effect of repair width on residual stresses of a stainless steel clad plate. International Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping, 2010, 87(8):457 − 463. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpvp.2010.06.003
|
[10] |
Deng D A, Zhang Y B, Li S. Influence of solid-state phase transformation on residual stress in P92 steel welded joint. Acta Metalluegica Sinca, 2016(4):394 − 402.
|
[11] |
Chen Q H, Lü X Q, Xu L Y. Microstructure and properties of CMT+P welded joints of P92 steel. Transactions of the China welding Institution, 2018, 39(12):110 − 140. (in Chinese)
|
Layer | Welding current I /A | Arc voltage U/V | Welding speed v /(mm.s−1) |
1 | 100 | 10 | 1 |
2–3 | 125 | 12 | 1 |
4 | 125 | 15 | 1 |
repair weld | 130 | 20 | 1 |